The disaster next door: 

The disaster next door

Context:

  • India’s stand on Rohingya refugees’ issues and its implications.

How India’s stance undermines its ties with Bangladesh and its regional leadership?

  • Rohingya refugees from the Rakhine state in Myanmar has put Bangladesh in a difficult situation.
  • Almost 300,000 refugees have taken shelter in squalid, unsanitary camps scattered along Myanmar-Bangladesh border in a span of two weeks.
  • The Myanmar authorities claim that 400 lives have been lost due to military action.

Where is India’s century old policy of Atithi Devo Bhava?

  • The Rohingya refugees have been shunned, denied basic public services in India where they have sought refuge in India.
  • The government has called them to be illegal immigrants and trespassers.
  • India has been generously accommodative towards refugees in the neighborhood fleeing persecution in the past.
  • India accommodated Parsis, Tibetans, Afghans, Sri Lankan Tamils, and Bangladeshis during the war of liberation in 1971.
  • India has prided itself in its tradition of Atithi Devo Bhava.
  • India’s stance on the Rohingya has been disappointing and is contradictory to the values of hospitality and inclusiveness.
  • India has overlooked the atrocities on Rakhine in the India-Myanmar joint statement.
  • Being a resource-constrained country, Bangladesh is badly impacted due to the refugee crisis.

What is the current situation in Bangladesh?

  • Bangladesh has been a role model of friendship in India’s neighborhood.
  • International relief agencies in Bangladesh (UNHCR, World Food Programme etc.) are struggling to attend to a large number of refugees arriving each day on foot or by boat.  
  • Bangladesh, itself one of the world’s most densely populated nations.
  • It has hosted more than 600,000 Rohingya compared to 40,000 by India.
  • It has plans of making another 607 hectares of land available near the Myanmar border for camps.
  • It has also urged the international community to put pressure on Myanmar to take back the refugees and stop the violence against them.

What are the implications?

  • India’s move to dissociate itself from the Bali Declaration puts into question its respect for human rights and the treatment of minorities.
  • The declaration claims to respect human rights of all people in Rakhine state.
  • It weakens India’s moral authority to speak for minorities in other parts of its neighborhood.
  • Small nations like Nepal, Bhutan and Sri Lanka joined the declaration.
  • Since 2009, Bangladesh has been addressing almost all security concerns of India and proved itself as a trusted neighbor.
  • The India-Bangladesh border today is one of the safest for India, enabling massive redeployment of its vital border resources for other purposes.
  • Bangladesh has neither received water from the Teesta or support in times of humanitarian crisis from its biggest neighbor.
  • The promptness is missing when it comes to supporting Bangladesh in distress situation.
  • Being the largest democracy in the region, India has can play an important role in resolving the Rohingya crisis in Myanmar.
  • Although Myanmar is an important stakeholder of India’s ‘Look East Policy’, its stand on the Rohingya crisis reflects lack of moral leadership.
  • India has failed to rise the occasion in extending its influence in the region.

Why has India failed in generating confidence in the region?

  • India fails to generate confidence in the region due to its complex geopolitics based more on political opportunism and economic interests as opposed to principles and values, practiced consistently.
Print Friendly and PDF
Blog
Academy
Community